I'm really pleased with my Lexus IS 250, and I think it's superior to my old BMW 318i.

I was looking for the same thing as MH and was considering Audi, BMW and Mercedes, but I saw a nice Lexus IS 250 Multimedia going through unsold at BCA in November and took a closer look. So I decided it was in a good price range and called my friend at Wellside Motors in Scotland who said the same thing about fuel. I then bought it at the next auction.

It is a car of superb build and far more advanced design than the BMW 318i I had before. Whereas the BMW had plenty of developed faults despite a BMW FSH, this car seems perfect apart from really gulping fuel if you use the impressive power, but I get 33mpg driving with restraint on the same run from London to Brentwood that the BMW only managed 35mpg, and the car is in a different level of comfort. You would only get the 16-inch wheels on a low spec but they might ride better. So far the only thing wrong is the key battery running low. It's the best car I've had.

Asked on 4 July 2012 by HT, Dunfermline

Answered by Honest John
Another reader who switched to 16-inch wheels has managed to extract 48mpg on one run in his IS 250 auto, but usually managed about 40mpg. Still a great and underestimated car. Deserves this publicity and, if it works, the value of yours may go up a bit.
Similar questions
Please advise on best engine choice for a used Focus estate (three to five years old) primarily regarding reliability and economy. Please also advise on tyre type for good mileage.
Being a little older and having driven Volkswagen Passats over the last 10 years, we now want a slightly smaller car but with the same comfortable ride; however, the distributors I have spoken to tell...
We currently own a Volkswagen Passat SE TDI 140 Auto which is now over three years old. We find it very comfortable but want to trade down to a smaller, equally comfortable car. What would you suggest?...
Related models
Superb to drive. Great handling and steering. Upmarket image. Economical diesel engines culminating in amazingly efficient 320d Efficient Dynamics at 109g/km of CO2.
Very well built. Top quality interior. Lexus dealers are best in the business. Impressive refinement. All engines chain cam. IS250 probably the most reliable car you can buy.