My warranty company won't repair my car because the recovery service was late - what can I do?

I bought a secondhand 1999 Audi A4 Avant at the end of July for £1800. It had done approx 97,000km in 11 yrs. I drove it the following week to France, where it broke down (problem as yet undiagnosed). The recovery people with whom I have European Deluxe cover picked the car up and spent a few days trying to find a garage that would diagnose the problem. All garages refused or said they were too busy (France is on holiday for the first two weeks of August) and the earliest anyone would look at it was two weeks later. It was decided to repatriate the vehicle to the UK on a lorry, and I was to fly back. This was all covered by the breakdown people.

Their policy states they will return the vehicle within 15 working days. The date was set as 9 September (action was agreed on 16 Aug). On the 9 September, I called the breakdown company to find out where the car was. They apologised and said that the company who were bringing it back had forgotten to pick the car up from France! A new date of Monday 13th Sept was given. The car arrived today to my named garage, Tuesday 14th Sept.

The issue is that my warranty that I purchased states that you have 14 days to inform them of the breakdown, which I did on day 13. You then have 14 days for the work to start on the vehicle to repair it, otherwise the warranty isn't valid. This would have happened if the vehicle came back on the original date. As a result of the delay, the 14 day deadline was missed and the warranty company will not cover the costs. Who, if anyone, is responsible? Do the breakdown people take responsibility for this as they are in breach of their 15 day policy to return the car?

Asked on 15 September 2010 by stemillion

Answered by Lucy
Whether the breakdown people might be held responsible will depend on whether the 15 day return is a policy or a guarantee. Otherwise talk to your warranty people and explain what has happened and see whether they may relent. However, be aware that warranties are insurance policies and if you are outside their terms they are within their rights not to pay out. In legal terms if you could have claimed under the warranty - ie it fell within the terms of what the warranty would repair other than for the delay - you may have a case to recover something from the breakdown firm, but it would be likely to be a highly speculative action and I would need to see the paperwork in full before committing as to whether you should bring it.
Similar questions
You recently wrote favourably regarding RAC Foreign Travel. For over 40 years my normal cars have been an XK120 and XK150. Most breakdown firms do not cover cars of this age, although I have only ever...
Can you advise concerning a blocked DPF, on our 2006 Jaguar S Type 2.7 diesel that caused a major breakdown at the end of a holiday on which we travelled at high speeds from Calais to the Costa Brava and...
I bought a 2003 Renault Laguna 2.2DCI Estate from a non-franchised local car centre last June. It had a new MOT but the advisory note said it had corroded brake discs (front and rear), an oil leak in the...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer